Mediation

Probate, Trust, Guardianship & Elder Law Disputes + Supported Decision-Making

Legal disputes involving probate estates, trusts, guardianships, and elder law issues require both deep legal knowledge and compassionate guidance. These matters often arise at emotionally stressful times — such as following the loss of a loved one, when a family member’s capacity changes, or when disagreements surface over financial control, decision-making authority, or rights and protections. At MC Law Group, we represent clients in disputes involving probate, trust administration, guardianship, elder law matters, and emerging alternatives like Supported Decision-Making (SDM) with clarity, experience, and practical advocacy.

Understanding Probate & Trust Disputes

Probate and trust disputes can stem from a wide variety of circumstances, including challenges to the validity of a will or trust, disagreements among beneficiaries or trustees, claims of undue influence, or allegations that a fiduciary failed to fulfill their duties. These disputes can delay estate administration, harm relationships, and reduce the value of assets ultimately available to loved ones.

Our attorneys help personal representatives, trustees, beneficiaries, and interested parties navigate:

  • Will contests and estate challenges
  • Trust validity and interpretation disputes
  • Trustee removal or breach of fiduciary duty claims
  • Accounting and asset distribution disagreements
  • Litigation and alternative dispute resolution

We tailor strategies that protect your interests while seeking efficient and fair resolution — whether through negotiation, mediation, or courtroom advocacy.

Guardianship & Elder Law Conflict Resolution

When a loved one’s ability to make decisions is questioned, families often find themselves facing guardianship proceedings or conflicts over what level of support is appropriate. Guardianship disputes can involve disagreements over whether guardianship is necessary, selection of the guardian, scope of authority, annual reporting issues, or allegations of abuse or mismanagement.

Our practice covers:

  • Guardianship establishment and defense
  • Guardian removal and modification proceedings
  • Guardianship advocacy alternatives
  • Financial exploitation protection
  • Elder abuse and neglect legal support

We approach these sensitive matters with a focus on preserving dignity, protecting rights, and finding solutions that balance safety with autonomy.

Speak to an elder law attorney near me.

Supported Decision-Making (SDM): A Modern Alternative

Supported Decision-Making (SDM) is a person-centered process that allows individuals with disabilities or cognitive impairments to make their own decisions with assistance from trusted supporters, rather than having decisions made for them by a guardian. SDM recognizes that many adults can make choices when given the right support — promoting autonomy, independence, and self-determination.

With SDM:

  • The individual selects supporters — such as family, friends, or professionals — to help them understand, weigh, and communicate decisions.
  • Supported Decision-Making Agreements can be formalized in writing to clarify roles and expectations.
  • The person retains the legal authority to decide for themselves, with supporters acting to help inform — not replace — the decision-making process.

Florida has formally integrated SDM into its legal landscape, and courts now must consider SDM before more restrictive options like guardianship when appropriate.

Why Disputes Arise in These Areas

Legal disputes in probate, trust, guardianship, and elder law often emerge when expectations, family dynamics, or interpretations of legal documents collide. Common triggers include:

  • Unclear will or trust language
  • Changes in family relationships or circumstances
  • Questions about capacity and decision-making ability
  • Accusations of financial mismanagement or elder exploitation
  • Confusion over roles and responsibilities

Whether the disagreement is among family members, between fiduciaries and beneficiaries, or involves interpretation of legal tools, engaging experienced counsel early can prevent escalation and protect rights.

How We Help

At MC Law Group, we provide comprehensive representation tailored to the emotional and legal complexities of these disputes. Our approach includes:

  • Thorough evaluation of your situation to identify legal risks and remedies
  • Clear explanation of your rights, options, and likely outcomes
  • Strategic planning whether aiming for negotiated resolution or trial
  • Coordination with other planning tools like powers of attorney, health care directives, and supported decision-making arrangements
  • Compassionate support for families under stress

We understand these disputes don’t happen in a vacuum. They involve real people, real relationships, and real consequences. Our goal is to protect your interests while preserving dignity and respect for all involved.

When to Seek Help

You may need trusted legal guidance if you or someone you care about is facing:

  • A contested will or trust issue
  • A dispute over trust administration or fiduciary conduct
  • Questions about whether guardianship is necessary or proper
  • Conflicts with a guardian or guardian advocate
  • Decisions about Supported Decision-Making
  • Elder financial exploitation or abuse concerns

No matter how complex the issue, early legal engagement increases your chances of a favorable outcome and reduces the potential for prolonged conflict.

Your Advocate in Probate, Trust, Guardianship & SDM Disputes

MC Law Group combines deep experience in estate and elder law with practical, results-oriented dispute resolution. We help clients understand their legal position, assert their rights, and work toward solutions that respect personal autonomy and legal protections — including less restrictive decision-making alternatives like SDM when appropriate.

If you’re facing a dispute involving probate, trust matters, guardianship, elder law issues, or Supported Decision-Making, we’re here to help with thoughtful counsel and dedicated representation.

McConnaughhay and Rudd, P.A. Logo

Our Practice Areas

Estate Planning

Estate planning allows individuals to proactively organize their assets through Wills, Trusts or other entities, to protect loved ones, and ensure their wishes are carried out clearly and efficiently.

Learn More

Probate Administration

Probate administration is the legal process of settling an estate, ensuring assets are properly distributed and obligations are handled in accordance with Florida law.

Learn More

Trust Administration

Trust administration involves managing and distributing trust assets in accordance with the trust’s terms while fulfilling all legal and fiduciary obligations.

Learn More

Special Needs Trusts

Special needs trusts are designed to preserve government benefits while providing long-term financial support for individuals with disabilities.

Learn More

Mediation

Alternative dispute resolution that is confidential and voluntary. McConnaughhay & Rudd offers mediation for complex probate estates, trusts, guardianships, and elder law issues requiring both dee

Learn More

Medicaid and Long-Term Care Planning

Medicaid and long-term care planning help individuals and families prepare for future care needs while protecting assets and maintaining financial stability.

Learn More

Guardianship

Guardianship proceedings provide legal protection for individuals who are unable to manage their personal or financial affairs, while ensuring their rights and best interests are safeguarded.

Learn More

Healthcare Directives

Health care directives allow individuals to clearly document their medical wishes and designate trusted decision-makers to ensure their preferences are honored if they cannot speak for themselves.

Learn More

Powers of Attorney

Powers of attorney enable individuals to appoint trusted agents to manage financial and legal matters on behalf of the individual.

Learn More

Contact an Experienced Law Firm in Tallahassee, FL

How Can We Help?

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.